Hey Nick,
As you already know, we live around the same area. Try 126.4 (NOBBI), 120.55 (HPN DEP), 124.075, 133.1 (SEALL), 120.8 (HAARP) to see what you can pick up off the N90 transmitters. My reception is pretty spotty here, but may be better where you are due to low/non-existent terrain.
Let me know how that works.
Regards,